Investing

401(k) Loan: Rules, Real Cost, and When It Makes Sense (2026)

Ad · Responsive
RETIREMENT401(k) Loan:Rules and Real Cost$20,000 over 5 years: interest paid at each rate401(k) loan at 8.00%: $4,332 (paid to your own account)Personal loan at 11.90%: $6,633Credit card at 22.36%: $13,389MyCalcFinance

A 401(k) loan lets you borrow up to the lesser of $50,000 or 50% of your vested balance. You repay it within five years at a rate your plan sets as a spread over prime, typically one or two points, so prime plus 1% is 8.00% today. On a $20,000 loan that's a payment of $406 a month and $4,332 of interest over five years, all of it paid back into your own account. The same $20,000 costs $13,389 of interest on a credit card at 22.36% and $6,633 on a personal loan at 11.90%, so the 401(k) loan is far cheaper than either.

So why do so many retirement guides warn you off it? Because the interest isn't where the cost sits. The cost is in what you stop contributing and in what happens if you change jobs before the balance is cleared. To see what a loan does to your own balance, start with our 401(k) calculator, then follow the math below.

Key Takeaways

  • The IRS caps a plan loan at the lesser of $50,000 or half your vested balance, repaid in at least quarterly payments within five years (longer only for buying your main home).
  • On a $20,000 loan at 8.00%, you pay $4,332 of interest to yourself. If your investments earn 7%, the account with the loan finishes $680 ahead after five years. It breaks even at 8% and falls $1,503 behind at 10%.
  • If you would have contributed $500 a month and pause it for the five loan years, you're $35,796 short at payoff and $204,950 short 25 years later at a 7% return. That is the real price.
  • 86% of workers who leave a job with a loan outstanding default on it (Lu, Mitchell, Utkus, Young, NBER 2015, on pre-2018 data). On the example loan, a default after two years means $12,941 taxed as income plus a $1,294 penalty if you're under 59½.
  • 13% of participants had a loan outstanding at year-end 2025, and 82% of plans offer them (Vanguard, How America Saves 2026).

The 2026 Rules in One Table

The rules come from section 72(p) of the tax code and the IRS pages that explain it. Your plan can be stricter than the law (many allow only one loan at a time, or none at all), but it can't be looser.

RuleWhat the IRS requires
Maximum loanThe lesser of $50,000 or 50% of your vested account balance. If the plan allows it, you can borrow up to $10,000 even when that exceeds 50% of your balance.
12-month lookbackThe $50,000 cap is reduced by the amount your highest outstanding loan balance in the previous 12 months exceeds the balance on the day of the new loan. Any balance still outstanding also counts against the cap.
Repayment termFive years maximum, except for a loan used to buy your principal residence, which the plan may stretch longer.
Payment scheduleSubstantially level payments of principal and interest, at least quarterly. Payroll deduction is the usual mechanism.
Interest rateA "reasonable" rate, in line with what lenders charge on similar loans (Department of Labor rule, 29 CFR §2550.408b-1). Plans express it as prime plus a spread. This article assumes prime plus 1%.
Missed paymentsThe plan may give a cure period, but it can't run past the end of the calendar quarter following the quarter the payment was due. Miss that and the whole balance plus accrued interest becomes a "deemed distribution" (Treas. Reg. §1.72(p)-1, Q&A-10).
Tax on defaultA deemed distribution or loan offset is taxed as ordinary income in that year. Under age 59½, the 10% additional tax on early distributions generally applies too.
Interest deductibilityNot deductible when the loan is secured by your elective deferrals, which is the normal case for a 401(k) loan (IRC §72(p)(3)).
FeesThe IRS doesn't set loan fees. Plans can charge an origination fee and an annual maintenance fee, and they must disclose them under the Department of Labor's fee-disclosure rules. Every figure in this article excludes fees, so add your plan's to the comparison.

What does the limit look like at different balances? The $10,000 floor only matters below a $20,000 vested balance, and only if your plan document includes it.

Vested balance50% ruleWith the $10,000 floor
$15,000$7,500$10,000
$25,000$12,500$12,500
$40,000$20,000$20,000
$80,000$40,000$40,000
$100,000 and up$50,000 cap$50,000 cap

One trap in the lookback rule: say your vested balance is $150,000, you still owe $10,000 on an older loan, and that loan's balance peaked at $30,000 within the past year. Your new loan is capped at $50,000 minus the $20,000 you paid down, minus the $10,000 still outstanding. That's $20,000, not $40,000. Paying a loan off fast doesn't reset the clock.

Where the Interest Rate Comes From

Plans don't set their own number from scratch. They tie the loan rate to the prime rate, and prime moves in lockstep with the Federal Reserve. Banks set prime three percentage points above the top of the Fed's target range. The Fed raised that range to 3.75%–4.00% on September 16, 2026, and held it there at its October 28, 2026 meeting, so prime has been 7.00% since mid-September. Prime plus 1% puts the example 401(k) loan at 8.00%. Your plan's loan policy states its own spread, and that's the number to plug in.

For the same five-year, $20,000 loan, here's what three borrowing options cost. The card rate is the Federal Reserve's G.19 figure for accounts that were charged interest in August 2026, and the personal loan rate is the G.19 24-month rate for the same month.

OptionRateMonthly payment (60 months)Total interestWho gets the interest
401(k) loan8.00% (prime + 1%)$406$4,332Your own account
Bank personal loan11.90%$444$6,633The bank
Credit card22.36%$556$13,389The card issuer
Total interest on $20,000 repaid over five years401(k) loan at 8.00%: $4,332 paid to your own account. Personal loan at 11.90%: $6,633. Credit card at 22.36%: $13,389. Rates: prime plus 1%, and Federal Reserve G.19 for August 2026.Total interest on $20,000 repaid over five yearsMonthly payments, monthly compounding$3,350$6,700$10,050$13,400401(k) loan 8.00%$4,332 to your own accountPersonal loan 11.90%$6,633Credit card 22.36%$13,389Sources: Federal Reserve G.19 (Aug 2026) via FRED TERMCBCCINTNS and TERMCBPER24NS; prime 7.00% + 1%. MyCalcFinance calculation.
Interest on a $20,000 loan repaid in 60 monthly payments. Card and personal loan rates are Federal Reserve G.19 figures for August 2026. Source: MyCalcFinance calculation.

Already carrying that card balance? The comparison gets worse. Paying the same $406 a month toward a $20,000 card balance at 22.36% takes 136 months and costs $34,975 in interest. Our credit card payoff calculator will run your own balance and rate.

Does Borrowing From Your 401(k) Really Cost You Growth?

Less than you'd think, and in some years, nothing. Take an $80,000 vested balance, borrow $20,000, and assume the money you left invested earns 7% a year. Without the loan, the account grows to $113,410 after five years. With the loan, the $60,000 you didn't borrow grows on its own, and each $406 payment is reinvested as it arrives. That path ends at $114,090. The loan comes out $680 ahead, because you paid yourself 8% while the market paid 7%. All of these figures are MyCalcFinance calculations with monthly compounding.

One caution on reading that result. The table isolates the account balance. It doesn't show the loan creating wealth, because the $24,332 of payments came out of your take-home pay, money the no-loan path kept. The fair comparison is against the debt you'd otherwise carry, which the rate table above covers.

Change the market assumption and the answer flips.

Market return during the loanNo loan, after 5 yearsWith the loanGap
4%$97,680$100,146Loan ahead by $2,466
5%$102,669$104,580Loan ahead by $1,911
7%$113,410$114,090Loan ahead by $680
8%$119,188$119,188Break-even
10%$131,625$130,121Loan behind by $1,503
Loan vs no loan: the five-year gap by market returnPoints left of zero mean the account with the loan is larger, points right of zero mean it is smaller. 4%: loan ahead $2,466. 5%: ahead $1,911. 7%: ahead $680. 8%: break-even. 10%: behind $1,503. Source: MyCalcFinance calculation.The loan only loses when the market beats your 8.00% loan rate$80,000 balance, $20,000 borrowed for five years, payments reinvested$0Loan ahead $2,000Behind $2,000Market 4%+$2,466Market 5%+$1,911Market 7%+$680Market 8%$0 break-evenMarket 10%−$1,503Source: MyCalcFinance calculation, monthly compounding, loan at 8.00% repaid over 60 months
Five-year gap between the account with and without the loan. The loan loses ground only when investments return more than the 8.00% you're paying yourself. Source: MyCalcFinance calculation.

The lesson isn't that a 401(k) loan is free. It's that the "lost compounding" argument depends entirely on the market beating 8% during your repayment years, and nobody knows that in advance. The two costs below don't depend on the market at all.

The Real Cost #1: Contributions You Stop Making

A $406 payment is 81% of a $500 monthly contribution. Few budgets have room for both, so the contribution quietly stops, and often the employer match stops with it. If you would have contributed $500 a month and pause it for the 60 loan months at a 7% return, you're $35,796 short on payoff day. Leave that gap unfilled for 25 more years to a retirement at 65 and it grows to $204,950.

That number dwarfs every other figure in this article. If you take the loan, the single most valuable thing you can do is keep contributing at least enough to capture the full employer match. Our 401(k) planning guide covers how the match and the 2026 limits work.

The Real Cost #2: Changing Jobs With a Balance Outstanding

Lu, Mitchell, Utkus, and Young studied Vanguard participant loan records. Nine out of ten loans are repaid. But 86% of workers who leave their job with a loan outstanding default on it (NBER Working Paper 21102, 2015, later published in the National Tax Journal, 2017). They estimate loan-default leakage from retirement accounts at $6 billion a year. The data predate the 2018 rollover extension described below, so today's default rate may be lower, but no newer study of this size has replaced it.

Why is the default so common? When you leave, many plans demand repayment in full or "offset" the loan, meaning they subtract the unpaid balance from your account and report it as a distribution. On the example loan, the balance after 24 payments is $12,941. At a 22% marginal rate that's $2,847 of federal income tax. Add a $1,294 early-distribution penalty if you're under 59½ and $4,141 is due with your return, on top of the $12,941 permanently gone from your retirement savings.

There's an escape hatch most people never hear about. Since 2018, a "qualified plan loan offset" caused by leaving your job can be rolled into an IRA or new employer's plan. The deadline is your tax filing date, including extensions, for the year of the offset (IRS, Plan loan offsets). You have to come up with the $12,941 from somewhere else to do it, but that turns a taxable default back into a tax-free rollover. If a job change is even a possibility in the next five years, this is the rule to remember.

The Double Taxation Argument, Sorted Out

You'll read that 401(k) loans are "double taxed." That's half right. The $20,000 principal isn't taxed twice. It was pre-tax going in, it's untaxed when you borrow it, and it's taxed once when you withdraw it in retirement, exactly as it would have been without the loan.

The interest is a different story. You pay the $4,332 of interest out of after-tax take-home pay, it lands in a pre-tax account, and it gets taxed again on the way out. At a 22% rate that's $953 of extra tax over the life of the money. Real, but small next to the paused-contribution figure, and it doesn't apply to a Roth 401(k) balance, where qualified withdrawals are tax-free. The Roth vs traditional 401(k) comparison explains that split.

When a 401(k) Loan Makes Sense

The math points to a narrow set of good uses, not a blanket yes or no.

  • Replacing credit card debt you'd otherwise carry for years. Swapping 22.36% for 8.00% paid to yourself saves $9,057 of interest on $20,000 over five years, and far more if you'd have been paying minimums. The condition: you don't run the cards back up. Our guide to paying off credit card debt covers the alternatives first.
  • A short-term bridge you can repay in one to two years. The two-year payment on $20,000 is $905 a month with $1,709 of total interest, and a short term shrinks the job-change window.
  • Your job is stable and you can keep contributing. Both costs above fall away if you stay put and don't pause your deferrals.

And when it doesn't:

  • You're interviewing, your employer is restructuring, or your industry has layoffs. The 86% default rate among job-changers in the Vanguard study is the number to respect, and the rollover window only helps if you can fund it.
  • You'd have to stop contributions, especially if that forfeits an employer match.
  • The loan funds consumption rather than retiring higher-rate debt or covering a true emergency. An emergency fund is the cheaper tool for the next one.
  • You're within a few years of retirement and would be repaying from a smaller income, or you'd still owe a balance when you leave.

Five Steps Before You Sign the Loan Paperwork

  1. Read your plan's loan policy. Ask the administrator for five things: the rate formula, the origination and annual fees, whether multiple loans are allowed, the cure period, and what happens at separation. If former employees can keep repaying by direct debit, most of the default risk disappears.
  2. Pick the shortest term you can afford. Run $20,000 at 24, 36, and 60 months ($905, $627, and $406 a month) and choose the shortest term whose payment doesn't force you to cut contributions.
  3. Protect the match. Set your deferral so the match stays intact before you size the loan payment.
  4. Plan the exit. Write down the payoff date and the rollover deadline rule in case you change jobs. Know where the remaining balance would come from.
  5. Compare it against the alternative in dollars. Put the loan's total interest, the alternative's total interest, and the growth gap side by side using the 401(k) calculator and the debt payoff calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much can you borrow from a 401(k)?

The lesser of $50,000 or 50% of your vested balance. The $50,000 cap is reduced by the amount your highest balance in the prior 12 months exceeds your current balance, and any existing loan balance counts against it. Plans may allow up to $10,000 even if that's more than half your balance. Your plan can set a lower cap or not offer loans at all. 82% of plans do (Vanguard, How America Saves 2026).

Does a 401(k) loan affect your credit score?

No. Plans don't run a credit check, and payments and defaults aren't reported to Experian, TransUnion, or Equifax (Experian). The consequences are tax consequences: the unpaid balance is reported to the IRS as a distribution on Form 1099-R. The indirect route is the tax and penalty bill, which can make it harder to pay other debts on time, and those missed payments do hurt your credit.

Can you pay a 401(k) loan off early?

Usually. Many plans allow early repayment without penalty (Experian), but check yours, because some restrict partial prepayments. Paying early cuts the interest and shortens the window in which a job change could trigger a default. Remember that the 12-month lookback still counts the paid-off balance against a new loan.

What happens to a 401(k) loan if you're laid off?

Many plans require repayment within a set period or offset the balance against your account. The offset is taxable, plus the 10% additional tax under 59½, unless you roll the offset amount into an IRA by your tax filing deadline including extensions. On the example loan, a default after two years costs $4,141 in tax and penalty at a 22% rate.

Is a 401(k) loan better than a hardship withdrawal?

Usually, yes. A hardship withdrawal is taxed as income, generally penalized under 59½, can't be repaid, and needs a qualifying hardship under your plan's rules. A loan is tax-free as long as it's repaid on schedule. If repayment looks unlikely, compare the tax on a default against the tax on a withdrawal. The bills are similar, and neither puts the money back.

Bottom Line

A 401(k) loan is cheap money: 8.00% paid to yourself, no credit check, and a growth cost that's small or zero unless the market beats your loan rate. The damage comes from two habits the interest math never shows, stopping contributions and leaving a job with a balance. Keep contributing, keep the term short, and know the rollover rule, and the loan can be a reasonable tool. Run your own balance in the 401(k) calculator before you decide, and check what the lost contributions would have grown into with the retirement calculator.

This article is educational, not tax or personal financial advice. Loan rates, repayment terms, and the 7% return are illustrations. All loan, growth, and tax figures are MyCalcFinance calculations using monthly compounding and a 22% federal marginal rate, excluding state tax and plan loan fees. Check your plan document and IRS guidance for your own situation.

Sources

Ad · Responsive

We use cookies for analytics and personalised advertising. By accepting, you allow these uses. See our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy.